Here's what I ended up making:
Style-ish! I love it ! Best of all you can write whatever message you want.
Remember, here's what the cooler looked like before it got the makeover:
Pretty Uggo! Besides Gatorade doesn't sponsor my pool parties so why should they get credit?
So I started out with the ugly cooler and covered it in a layer of primer. As thus:
I think primer is necessary because it's such a smooth surface.
After the primer dried, I covered it in about 50 bazillian layers of chalk spray paint. Once that's dry you're pretty much done. Easy right? So stinking easy. I love chalk paint!!!!